[clas12_rgk] [EXTERNAL] Re: Internal jeopardy review for PAC48 - RG-K document

[Dave Ireland]

Hi Viktor,

Thanks for this input. I will discuss with Annalisa tomorrow how best to 
make these points forcefully in the document.

Cheers,

Dave




On 03/06/2020 12:21, Viktor Mokeev wrote:
> Dear  All,
> 
> Studies of gvpN* electrocouplings in KY are absolutely needed in order 
> to validate the hybrid nature of the candidate hybrid state in the mass 
> region from 2.0 GeV to 2.5 GeV. They are the important part in a search 
> for hybrid baryons.
> 
>   The measurements of the transition gvpN* electrocouplings in KY 
> electroproduction addresses the important topics: A) the evolution of 
> active degree of freedom in the N* structure with distance and how 
> different this evolution is for the resonances of different masses and 
> spin-parities; B ) how meson-baryon cloud emerges from quark-gluon 
> confinement regime.
> 
> Understanding the role of glue as baryon constituent and getting insight 
> into the  N* structure for all prominent and different excited nucleons 
> are really critical in order to explore the strong interaction in regime 
> of large QCD running coupling, the so called strong QCD regime which is 
> the last mostly unexplored part  of the Standard Model.
> 
>     Best Regards,
>                                     Victor
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------
> *From:* Annalisa D'Angelo <annalisa.dangelo at roma2.infn.it>
> *Sent:* Wednesday, June 3, 2020 5:26 AM
> *To:* Dave Ireland <David.Ireland at glasgow.ac.uk>; Kyungseon Joo 
> <kjoo at jlab.org>
> *Cc:* clas12_rgk at jlab.org <clas12_rgk at jlab.org>; Ralf Gothe 
> <rwgothe at gmail.com>; Viktor Mokeev <mokeev at jlab.org>; Latifa Elouadrhiri 
> <latifa at jlab.org>; Volker Burkert <burkert at jlab.org>; Daniel Carman 
> <carman at jlab.org>; Francois-Xavier Girod-Gard <fxgirod at jlab.org>; 
> Charles Hyde-Wright <hyde at jlab.org>; Meziani, Zein-Eddine <zmeziani at anl.gov>
> *Subject:* [EXTERNAL] Re: Internal jeopardy review for PAC48 - RG-K 
> document
> Dear Dave,
> thank you for your very constructive inputs. This week I would be 
> available to meet:
> 
>   * tomorrow from 11:00 to 13:00 (central European Time)
>   * Friday from 9:00 to 13:00 (central European Time)
> 
> You can set-up a Zoom meeting, if you prefer: I made it work!
> All the best
> Annalisa
> 
> 
> Il 03/06/20 10:40, Dave Ireland ha scritto:
>> Dear Annalisa,
>>
>> Please find attached the review committee's initial comments on the 
>> run group K jeopardy document. You may need clarification on what some 
>> comments mean, so we would encourage you to discuss these in a call 
>> with us. As you know, I am the lead reviewer for this run group, so 
>> would be the first person to contact, but the others are happy to 
>> participate if the time is available.
>>
>> Kyungseon's timeline (below) is for revised documents to be submitted 
>> by June 9.
>>
>> Best wishes,
>>
>> Dave,
>> for the jeopardy committee:
>> Charles Hyde-Wright
>> Zein-Eddine Meziani
>>
>> -----
>>
>> Timeline:
>> • 4/22/2020: Committee members start to communicate with run-group 
>> leaders. [DONE]
>> • 5/26/2020: Run-group leaders send their initial draft due to Chair 
>> of jeopardy review committee. [DONE]
>> • 6/2/2020: First round recommendations sent to run group-leaders [DONE]
>> • 6/9/2020: Revised documents sent to Chair of jeopardy review committee
>> • 6/16/2020: Final recommendations sent to run group-leaders
>> • 6/22/2020: Submit jeopardy updates due to PAC48
>>
>>
>>
>> On 26/05/2020 10:55, Annalisa D'Angelo wrote:
>>> To the Chair of the CLAS Internal Review Committee - Prof. David Ireland
>>>
>>> To the Chair of the CLAS Collaboration - Prof. Kyungseon Joo
>>>
>>> please find in attachment the Initial draft of the document we are 
>>> preparing for the PAC48  Jeopardy Review Committee. The document 
>>> reflects the present status of the preliminary analysis of the 
>>> available RG-K fall 2018 data. We expect to improve some of the 
>>> figures, such as Figure 3, in the next weeks, possibly refining the 
>>> statistics and the fit quality.
>>>
>>> We are also preparing additional material, dedicated to a more 
>>> detailed description of the data analysis procedure, which is posted 
>>> on a dedicated web RG-K wiki page, which is available at the link:
>>>
>>> All the material, including the attached document is available on the 
>>> , at the link:
>>>
>>> https://clasweb.jlab.org/wiki/index.php/Run_Group_K#tab=Jeopardy_Document 
>>>
>>>
>>> Please note that the present list of authors is limited to the list 
>>> of PI and dedicated students and post-doc. We are planning to 
>>> circulate the document among the original list authors to verify that 
>>> the scientific interest of the scientists and the institutes they 
>>> belong to is still vivid.
>>>
>>> We will be pleased to promptly address all your inputs to improve the 
>>> quality of the scope of the document.
>>>
>>> Thank you for your attention and support
>>>
>>> Annalisa D'Angelo
>>>
>>> for the RG-K
>>>
> -- 
> ================================================
> Prof. Annalisa D'Angelo
> Dip. Fisica, Universita' di Roma "Tor Vergata"
> Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare
> Sezione di Roma Tor Vergata, Rome Italy
> email:annalisa.dangelo at roma2.infn.it  <mailto:email:annalisa.dangelo at roma2.infn.it>  
> Jefferson Laboratory, Newport News, VA USA
> Email:annalisa at jlab.org  <mailto:annalisa at jlab.org>
> Tel: + 39 06 72594562
>