[clas12_rgk] [EXTERNAL] comparison between denoising and no-denoising rgk dst and skims

[Lucilla Lanza]

Dear all,

following Raffaella's instructions I attempted a recovery of the skims. 
You can find the new files at:

6.5 GeV denoise (5901,5906,5913,5920,5986,5990):

/volatile/clas12//rg-k/production/recon/fall2018/torus+1/6535MeV/pass1/v19/denoise_new/train/

6.5 GeV no denoise (5901,5906,5913,5920,5986,5990):

/volatile/clas12//rg-k/production/recon/fall2018/torus+1/6535MeV/pass1/v19/no_denoise_new/train/

7.5 GeV no denoise (5682,5696,5700,5708,5734,5791):

/volatile/clas12//rg-k/production/recon/fall2018/torus+1/7546MeV/pass1/v19/no_denoise_new/train/

Please let me know if you have any comment or queston.
Best regards,

Lucilla

> Il 2023-07-25 22:06 Raffaella De Vita ha scritto:
>> Dear Lucilla,
>> 
>> Daniel noticed the REC::Scintillator banks in the skims seem to be
>> corrupted. I did some investigation and found that the version of the
>> train that was run is based on an old coatjava version where the
>> REC::Scintillator bank was different than what it is now. This is
>> likely the cause of the problem.
>> 
>> We verified the skims can be recovered (with no need to rerun the
>> trains), replacing the bank schema in the files. This can be done
>> running the following command for each of the skim files;
>> 
>> hipo-utils -update -d
>> /group/clas12/packages/clara/5.0.2_10.0.2/plugins/clas12/etc/bankdefs/hipo4
>> -o recovered-skim.hipo original-skim.hipo
>> 
>> which basically restores the correct schema.
>> 
>> My suggestion is to create a new directory where to write the
>> recovered files with the same directory structure as the train output.
>> Let me know if you have any questions.
>> 
>> Best regards,
>> 	Raffaella
>> 
>> 
>>> On 24 Jul 2023, at 09:28, Lucilla Lanza <lucilla.lanza at roma2.infn.it> 
>>> wrote:
>>> 
>>> Dear all,
>>> 
>>> the rgk dst files with (5901,5906,5913,5920,5986,5990) and without 
>>> (5682,5696,5700,5708,5734,5791,5901,5906,5913,5920,5986,5990) 
>>> denoising applied are available for comparison (coatjava 10.0.2, 
>>> timestamp 07/15/2023-03:00:00).
>>> 
>>> No denoising:
>>> 
>>> /volatile/clas12/rg-k/production/recon/fall2018/torus+1/6535MeV/pass0/v0_cook_no_denoise_new/dst/recon/
>>> 
>>> Denoising:
>>> 
>>> /volatile/clas12/rg-k/production/recon/fall2018/torus+1/6535MeV/pass0/v0_cook_denoise_new/dst/recon/
>>> 
>>> You can find the corresponding skims with and without denoising 
>>> applied at:
>>> 
>>> 6.5 GeV denoise (5901,5906,5913,5920,5986,5990):
>>> 
>>> /volatile/clas12//rg-k/production/recon/fall2018/torus+1/6535MeV/pass1/v19/denoise/train/
>>> 
>>> 7.5 GeV no denoise (5682,5696,5700,5708,5734,5791):
>>> 
>>> /volatile/clas12//rg-k/production/recon/fall2018/torus+1/7546MeV/pass1/v19/no_denoise/train/
>>> 
>>> 6.5 GeV no denoise (5901,5906,5913,5920,5986,5990):
>>> 
>>> /volatile/clas12//rg-k/production/recon/fall2018/torus+1/6535MeV/pass1/v19/no_denoise/train/
>>> 
>>> Please let me know if you have any comment or question.
>>> Best regards,
>>> 
>>> Lucilla
>>> 
>>>