[Clascomment] Your papers

[Marco Ripani]

Dear lead authors of the omega and eta-etaprime papers,
you have a nice physics paper on the PWA that however you are planning 
to submit to a different journal, PRD, while the data would be published 
on PRC. I don't know the PRC publication policy so much to judge whether 
they would accept the PWA paper as a separate paper, but wouldn't it be 
much better to have data and physics appearing back-to-back on the same 
journal ? What's the rationale behind sending the two papers to two 
different journals ? The journal policy, other reasons of opportunity ?
In the case of the eta/etaprime, I understand that there is no 
meaningful comparison to theories to be made or an accompanying PWA 
analysis, but here you have a great deal of physics that makes me think 
there would be much added value if the two papers appeared together.

Best Regards
Marco

--