OPT-IN:Extraction of A^sin(Ï)_LU moments from the hard exclusive Ï^+ channel off the unpolarized hydrogen target in a wide range of kinematics
Stepan Stepanyan
stepanya at jlab.org
Sat Feb 1 11:04:04 EST 2020
Nice work, here are my comments:
- definition of kinematic variables, Q2, x_B, t, W
- What is the meaning of the order of the grouped references? e.g. [1-11], or [12-20], or [21-31]. It make more sense to have a chronological order of these grouped references, it will give a better sense of the development of the field and correct credit to authors
- a sentence for using a âskewed Gaussianâ and explanation of it will be useful
- why cos(\phi) and cos(2\phi) moments have not been studied with sidebands?
- page 4, looks like calculations of the sin(\phi) moment neglect cos(\phi) and cos(2\phi) moments (A_{UU}). In the fits to the integrated A_{LU} in Fig.3 they are ~10-12%, how much is the contribution of these two terms for each t-bin in Fig.4?
- page 4, right column, last paragraph, how it is clearly seen that asymmetry is constrained to 0 at t=t_{min}? Looks like at the smallest t-point the asymmetry is still sizable.
- Fig.6, for consistency with Fig.3 and 3, it might be better to have the forward region in the left and the backward in the right side in the figure.
More information about the Clascomment
mailing list