[Clascomment] [EXTERNAL] Re: OPT-IN:First comprehensive measurement of spin observables and differential cross sections dsigma/dt in omega photoproduction off the proton for 2.7 < Egamma < 5.2 GeV using CLAS

[Stepan Stepanyan]

Dear Volker,

Thanks for considering my comments. On the two points below

> 
>> - line 63, the sentence is unclear, “The low-energy regime close to the reaction threshold, where nucleon resonances dominate the photoproduction of ω mesons, and the Regge regime are analytically connected. “ either unfinished sentence or may be “and” must be removed?
>      —> I am not sure about this comment. The sentence looks good to me and would make little sense without the word “and.”
I am sure this is my issue then, I think I know what you are saying - the low energy and the Regge regimes are analytically connected - but I did not read it that way.  

>> - caption of Fig.3, it does not look like the definition of red curves in Fig.2, and Fig.3 are the same
>      —> Can you please clarify why you think the definitions are different? Looks good to me.
I got confused with the different red lines on the different plots, looks fine.

Regards, Stepan