[Deeppwg] Fwd: NSTAR proceedings

[Daria Sokhan]

Dear everyone,

Please also see Michel Garçon's comment below (it bounced from the list).

Michel, I should have noted that the kinematics is slightly different
between the Hall A result and mine. I will look up my average x, Q^2, t and
also quote them.

What is the general feeling on showing the BSA? I could show the plot but
mask the y-scale, for example...

Many thanks,
Daria


On 2 December 2015 at 08:19, Garcon Michel <Michel.Garcon at cea.fr> wrote:

> Dear Daria et al.,
>
>
>
>                 I am in general in favor of waiting until there is a
> submitted analysis note to preliminary results in proceedings, except if
> the recognition of the work of a student or post-doc cannot wait, or if the
> work was presented and discussed without any show stopper in the DP-PWG.
> This being said, I accept that we have flexible rules.
>
>
>
>                 In this particular case, even for the case of BSA, the
> fact that a number of corrections have not been done (pi0 subtraction,..),
> combined with the observation that the result may seem at variance with
> Hall A results where the asymmetry on the neutron was found compatible with
> 0, should question us. You acknowledge in the text that the results may
> still change significantly! I would then not be in favor of publishing
> these preliminary results at this stage.
>
>
>
>                 My two cents,
>
>                                Michel.
>
>
>
> *_______________*
>
> *Michel Garçon*
>
> *Irfu/SPhN                                               *
>
> *CEA-Saclay, bât. 703                               *
>
> *91191 Gif-sur-Yvette cedex        *
>
> *France                                          *
>
> *Tél.:** +33 1 69 08 86 23 <%2B33%201%2069%2008%2086%2023>*
>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://mailman.jlab.org/pipermail/deeppwg/attachments/20151202/85d5e77e/attachment.html>