[Deeppwg] [Clas12_deepana] CLAS12 Deep Process Analysis Meeting and Review

[Marco Contalbrigo]

Dear Valery,
the formal procedure for the intermediate results you are speaking about 
is not too restrict. Considering this would be the first time we are
making CLAS12 result public I would however be pretty careful.

- We did not explicitly discuss the release of these plots at the
meeting, with the only exception of pi0 mass spectrum.

- In principle these are only supporting plots, however they could
inherit detector related details we do not want to disseminate
without a better comprehension and a sub-detector expert approval
that goes beyond DPWG competence.

- Any released plot become a precedent and therefore should be taken
as a reference for subsequent presentations; I dislike the case
we produce several revisions of the same preliminary plot.
We better aim to a set of official plots we trust be under control.
E.g., I do not feel the discussion about HTCC Npe plot was conclusive
today.

All together, I strongly recommend any plot based on CLAS12 data
intended to be shown at the Conference is included in the releasing
note Harut and Stefan are preparing and submitted for RGA and CLAS 
management approval, meanwhile circulated among DPWG for knowledge
and final inspection.

Best regards, Marco.

On Thu, 6 Sep 2018, Valery Kubarovsky wrote:

> Dear Marco,
> 
> As I understood from the today's meeting I can show at the conference simple CLAS12 distributions such as
> 
> - gamma-gamma invariant mass with the pi0 signal,
> - beta vs momentum distribution for the demonstration of the TOF PID
> - number of photoelectrons in HTCC
> - energy resolution of our e/m calorimeters
>  
> I don't have any histograms with the physics results.
> 
> best,
> Valery
> 
> ________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
>       From: "Contalbrigo Marco" <mcontalb at fe.infn.it>
>       To: "CLAS12 Deep Process Analysis" <clas12_deepana at jlab.org>, "clas12 first exp"
>       <clas12_first_exp at jlab.org>, deeppwg at jlab.org
>       Sent: Thursday, September 6, 2018 6:25:19 AM
>       Subject: Re: [Clas12_deepana] CLAS12 Deep Process Analysis Meeting and Review
>
>       Dear all,
>       the material has been posted at the DPANA web page
>       (see below). See you there, Marco.
>
>       On Wed, 5 Sep 2018, Marco Contalbrigo wrote:
>
>       > Dear all,
>       > let me remind there will be a DPANA meeting tomorrow,
>       > Thursday September 6th at 8:30 am EST. It would be
>       > an important meeting, see below.
>       >
>       > The important SPIN2018 Symposium will be held next week
>       > in Ferrara, Italy. It is an importan occasion where to
>       > advertise CLAS12 data taking start (Harut, Marco M.
>       > and Valery will be there).
>       >
>       > As agreeded at the last meeting, Stefan, Giovanni and
>       > Harut will present a report of their advanced SIDIS
>       > studies at the DPANA meeting tomorrow. DPWG might be
>       > able to release some preliminary plots to be submitted
>       > to RGA and CLAS management for approval to be show at
>       > the Conference.
>       >
>       > Let me stress once more that the current focus should be
>       > to demonstrate that CLAS12 is alive and operative, more
>       > than attempt dissemination of premature physics results.
>       > In this sense any intermediate result as kinematic
>       > distribution or convincing DATA vs MC comparison would
>       > be already effecive.
>       >
>       > As usual, everybody is welcome to contribute with
>       > his/her own study.
>       >
>       > Hope to see you at the meeting.
>       > Below the coordinates.
>       > Marco.
>       >
>       >>>   JLab seminar room: F226
>       >>>
>       >>>   Agenda of the meeting available at:
>       >>>   https://clas12-docdb.jlab.org/cgi-bin/DocDB/private/DisplayMeeting?conferenceid=9
>       >>>
>       >>>   To join the meeting:
>       >>>  https://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=https-3A__bluejeans.com_551610659&d=DwIBAg&c=lz9TcOasaINaaC3U7FbMev2lsutwpI4
> --09aP8Lu18s&r=VX70eZFUAkN25MzbimADcwXq-GV00MydhomdtiZFTu0&m=2lpHiwJB_ER5Gqo7EXvVg0zluihlQu06thGmWSQuUU0&s=mdZ7WwG5iCS
>       fFvYJk7F1SQCg8ImcAV8Av9B4lnR79Lw&e=
>       >>>
>       >>>   To join via Room System:
>       >>>   Video Conferencing System: bjn.vc -or-199.48.152.152
>       >>>   Meeting ID : 551610659
>       >>>
>       >>>   To join via phone :
>       >>>
>       >>>   1) Dial:
>       >>>   +1.408.740.7256 (United States)
>       >>>   +1.888.240.2560 (US Toll Free)
>       >>>   +1.408.317.9253 (Alternate number)
>       >>>   (see all numbers -https://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=http-3A__bluejeans.com_numbers&d=DwIBAg&c=lz9TcOasaINaaC3U7FbMev2lsutwpI4--0
> 9aP8Lu18s&r=VX70eZFUAkN25MzbimADcwXq-GV00MydhomdtiZFTu0&m=2lpHiwJB_ER5Gqo7EXvVg0zluihlQu06thGmWSQuUU0&s=O4ozAQ50OpJfoa
>       kpc6rNLYpNdTffkh8RaZ7UyqTmCi4&e= )
>       >>>
>       >>>   2) Enter Conference ID : 551610659
>       >>>
>       >>>   See you, Marco.
>       >>>
>       >>>
>       >>>
>       >>
>       >>
>       >
>
>       _______________________________________________
>       Clas12_deepana mailing list
>       Clas12_deepana at jlab.org
>       https://mailman.jlab.org/mailman/listinfo/clas12_deepana
> 
> 
>