[G12] phi-Theta analysis from g12

[Amaryan, Moskov]

Dear Paul,

Thank you for taking a time to read and comment on our note.
As you well know our analysis has already its own history of
ancient times, middle ages and modern time.
So the modern time, one year analysis review has been finalized just 
a few months ago. There are no doubts raised on the validity of 
both g11 data analysis and phi Monte Carlo performed based on
Titov-Lee model. The only question that remained to be clarified 
is related to the application of the t-cut. Secondly the committee
and subsequently CLAS Coordination Committee have suggested
to look at g12 data to see if similar resonance structure persits in
a new data set.

Nobody, including us, is able to explain appearence of 
statistically very significant anomaly in the missing mass of kshort.

This a bottom line of the modern era.

For the sake of effectiveness I invite you and other readers of our note
to forget surrounding rumors and incomplete counter argumentations.

Best regards,

Moskov.

"Have the courage to use your own understanding !"

Immanuel Kant
________________________________________
From: g12-bounces at jlab.org [g12-bounces at jlab.org] On Behalf Of Paul Eugenio [eugenio at fsu.edu]
Sent: Wednesday, April 14, 2010 9:57 AM
To: Amaryan, Moskov
Cc: g12 at jlab.org; Eugene Pasyuk
Subject: Re: [G12] phi-Theta analysis from g12

Dear  Moskov,

I have spent some time looking over your note.  To first order, I am really not surprised that the same peak exists.  Some time back, it was shown by Bellis & company that cuts on phase-space monte carlo exhibit a peak in the same mass range.  If this is true, then the same phase-space artifact would show up also under similar constraints in the g12 data.

As for presenting preliminary results to the g12 group, we meet Wednesday's at 12:00 via teleconference(see g12 wiki).  We will put you on next week's agenda.

Paul



--
Prof. Paul Eugenio
Florida State University
Department of Physics
Tallahassee, Florida,  USA 32306

(850) 644-2585
eugenio at fsu.edu



On Apr 10, 2010, at 4:24 PM, Moskov Amaryan wrote:

> Dear Dennis, Paul and g12 enthusiasts,
>
> we are glad to let you know that already at this
> preliminary stage of the analysis of beautiful g12 data
> we have confirmed results of ODU g11 data analysis
> on phi-Theta interference with resonance structure
> observed at 1.54 GeV in the missing mass of kshort.
>
> Our note is attached to this message.
>
> Please let us know the appropriate time to present
> them to g12 group to have some discussion and to get
> further suggestions.
>
> Best regards,
>
> Moskov.
>
> <g12.pdf>


_______________________________________________
G12 mailing list
G12 at jlab.org
https://mailman.jlab.org/mailman/listinfo/g12