[Hybrid baryons] Updated version of hybrid proposal

[Viktor Mokeev]

  Dear All,

 I strongly support the first two comments by Gleb and Iulia. After the recent evaluation of the minimal values of gvpN* electrocouplings,
the Section 7.8 in the current version looks as obsolete.

 Best Regards,
                    Victor

----- Original Message -----
From: "Gleb Fedotov" <glebfedotov at gmail.com>
To: "hybrid baryons" <hybrid_baryons at jlab.org>
Sent: Sunday, May 22, 2016 1:14:40 PM
Subject: Re: [Hybrid baryons] Updated version of hybrid proposal

Dear Daniel,

there are still some inconsistencies in the text. So I suggest the
following changes:

page 55, Section 7.8, paragraph 1

"are based on employing small bin sizes of \Delta Q2 ~ 0.1 GeV2" ->
"are based on employing bin size of \Delta Q2 ~ 0.1 GeV2 for KY and
\Delta Q2 ~ 0.3 GeV2 for \pi+\pi-p"

same page and section, paragraph 2

remove the following part:

"We have re-evaluated the minimal values for the electrocouplings
above which the hybrid
signal will be statistically significant accounting for the data
collection in the larger bins
of Q2. Our evaluation of the .+.−p channel sensitivity to a hybrid
signal is based on
the minimal value of the resonance electrocouplings determined in the
analysis [29] of the
CLAS data [50] that was collected in a bin of ¢Q2 = 0.3 GeV2 at
Q2=0.65 GeV2. The
minimal absolute values of the resonance electrocouplings obtained
from these CLAS data
were . 30(10−3) GeV−1/2 [7]."

page 59, paragraph 1

"with A1/2 set to the minimal value needed for the observation of the hybrid
state in the data (see Table 5)," -> "with nonzero A1/2"

caption to the Fig 44.

"with A1/2 set to the minimal value for the hybrid state observation
(seeTable 5)" -> "with A1/2 = 37"

page 60, paragraph 2

remove "with the hadronic parameters listed in Table 5 of Section 7.5 for
the minimal values of A1/2(Q2) needed for the observation of the state
in the data."

caption to the Fig 46.

"with A1/2 equal to the minimal value for the hybrid state observation
(see Table 5)" -> "with nonzero A1/2"

Best regards,
         Gleb & Iuliia.


On Sat, May 21, 2016 at 5:19 PM,  <golovach at jlab.org> wrote:
> Daniel,
>
> Page 61. Caption of Fig.45.
> S1/2 -> S_{1/2}
>
> Page 61. The 4-th line from the bottom of the page.
> chi^2 -> \chi^2
>
> Page 72.
> Do we need to write down the explicit definitions of
> the Wigner d-functions and their properties?
> They are standard and there is a definition in any
> issue of the "Review of particle physics" from PDG.
>
> Evgeny
>
>
>>   Hi Dan,
>>
>>  Please change:
>>
>> Skobeltsyn Inst. of Physics,----> Skobeltsyn Inst. of Nuclear Physics,
>>
>>  Best Regards,
>>                        Victor
>>
>> ----- Original Message -----
>> From: "Daniel Carman" <carman at jlab.org>
>> To: "hybrid baryons" <hybrid_baryons at jlab.org>
>> Sent: Friday, May 20, 2016 2:41:16 PM
>> Subject: [Hybrid baryons] Updated version of hybrid proposal
>>
>> Folks,
>>
>> After a long week of work to update the version of the proposal to
>> incorporate the changes
>> due to the feedback from the CLAS review committee and due to further work
>> since our
>> initial submission, we have finally converged with a version ready for
>> everyone to look over.
>>
>> Attached is the updated version of the proposal and a draft of the
>> point-by-point replies
>> to the comments raised by the committee.
>>
>> The goal is to resubmit the proposal by Monday at noon (JLab time) in
>> order to allow for
>> final review by the committee and a preparation of their final report.
>> Please look things
>> over and let me know by Monday at 8 a.m. (JLab time) at the latest if you
>> have any
>> comments or find any problems.
>>
>> When the draft is complete on Monday, everything will be sent to Annalisa
>> to complete
>> the resubmission work.
>>
>> Thanks to everyone for their hard work in getting to this point.
>>
>> Regards,
>> Daniel
>>
>> ***********************************************************************************
>> *
>>                                         *
>> * Dr. Daniel S. Carman                  e-mail : carman at jlab.org
>>           *
>> * Staff Scientist                              office : (757)-269-5586
>>                     *
>> * Jefferson Laboratory                   web:
>> http://userweb.jlab.org/~carman  *
>> *
>>                                         *
>> ***********************************************************************************
>>
>> _______________________________________________
>> Hybrid_baryons mailing list
>> Hybrid_baryons at jlab.org
>> https://mailman.jlab.org/mailman/listinfo/hybrid_baryons
>> _______________________________________________
>> Hybrid_baryons mailing list
>> Hybrid_baryons at jlab.org
>> https://mailman.jlab.org/mailman/listinfo/hybrid_baryons
>>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Hybrid_baryons mailing list
> Hybrid_baryons at jlab.org
> https://mailman.jlab.org/mailman/listinfo/hybrid_baryons

_______________________________________________
Hybrid_baryons mailing list
Hybrid_baryons at jlab.org
https://mailman.jlab.org/mailman/listinfo/hybrid_baryons