[Nuclear] status talk for informal T2K neutrino interactions working group

[Jerry Gilfoyle]

Hi Folks,

Steve Manly is giving an update to one of the neutrino working groups that
includes some of his recent simulation results and spectra from EG2. I have
attached his talk. Please let me and him know if there are changes needed.
My comments are below.

Jerry

----

Comments from me:

The similarity of the GENIE and CLAS results is very interesting!

1. You should include a few more details on the EG2 run like the number of
electron events, target configuration (thicknesses, used simultaneous
multiple targets), beam energy, Q2 range (it's in the plots later on, but
make it explicit).

2. For the magnetic field map on page 4, can you state the value of position
along the beam line?

3. For the plots on page 6, you need some explanatory text. Should say these
plots are for a proton target so they are not(?) from EG2.

4. For the plots on pages 8-10, the GENIE events were presumably run through
GSIM which should be stated explicitly. It looks like the integrals of the
different spectra from CLAS and GENIE are the same. How did you get this
result (scale the histograms?, tune the GENIE inputs?)? This should be
stated.

Looks good otherwise.


-- 
Dr. Gerard P. Gilfoyle
Physics Department
University of Richmond, VA 23173  USA
e-mail: ggilfoyl at richmond.edu
phone:  804-289-8255
fax:    804-484-1542
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: https://mailman.jlab.org/pipermail/nuclear/attachments/20100111/5d953afb/attachment-0001.html 
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: manly.pdf
Type: application/pdf
Size: 982840 bytes
Desc: not available
Url : https://mailman.jlab.org/pipermail/nuclear/attachments/20100111/5d953afb/attachment-0001.pdf