[clas12_rgk] [EXTERNAL] Re: Internal jeopardy review for PAC48 - RG-K document - second version

[Dave Ireland]

Dear Annalisa,

Thanks very much for the updated documment. We will get back to you by 
June 16 at the latest; hopefully before that.

Best wishes,

Dave



On 10/06/2020 09:45, Annalisa D'Angelo wrote:
> To the Chair of the CLAS Internal Review Committee - Prof. David Ireland
> 
> To the Chair of the CLAS Collaboration - Prof. Kyungseon Joo
> 
> please find in attachment the second version of the document we are 
> preparing for the PAC48  Jeopardy Review Committee, together with the 
> detailed replay to the First Round comments.
> 
> All the material, including the attached document is also available on 
> the , at the link:
> 
> https://clasweb.jlab.org/wiki/index.php/Run_Group_K#tab=Jeopardy_Document
> 
> 
> Thank you for your attention and support
> 
> Annalisa D'Angelo
> 
> for the RG-K
> Il 03/06/20 10:40, Dave Ireland ha scritto:
>> Dear Annalisa,
>>
>> Please find attached the review committee's initial comments on the 
>> run group K jeopardy document. You may need clarification on what some 
>> comments mean, so we would encourage you to discuss these in a call 
>> with us. As you know, I am the lead reviewer for this run group, so 
>> would be the first person to contact, but the others are happy to 
>> participate if the time is available.
>>
>> Kyungseon's timeline (below) is for revised documents to be submitted 
>> by June 9.
>>
>> Best wishes,
>>
>> Dave,
>> for the jeopardy committee:
>> Charles Hyde-Wright
>> Zein-Eddine Meziani
>>
>> -----
>>
>> Timeline:
>> • 4/22/2020: Committee members start to communicate with run-group 
>> leaders. [DONE]
>> • 5/26/2020: Run-group leaders send their initial draft due to Chair 
>> of jeopardy review committee. [DONE]
>> • 6/2/2020: First round recommendations sent to run group-leaders [DONE]
>> • 6/9/2020: Revised documents sent to Chair of jeopardy review committee
>> • 6/16/2020: Final recommendations sent to run group-leaders
>> • 6/22/2020: Submit jeopardy updates due to PAC48
>>
>>
>>
>> On 26/05/2020 10:55, Annalisa D'Angelo wrote:
>>> To the Chair of the CLAS Internal Review Committee - Prof. David Ireland
>>>
>>> To the Chair of the CLAS Collaboration - Prof. Kyungseon Joo
>>>
>>> please find in attachment the Initial draft of the document we are 
>>> preparing for the PAC48  Jeopardy Review Committee. The document 
>>> reflects the present status of the preliminary analysis of the 
>>> available RG-K fall 2018 data. We expect to improve some of the 
>>> figures, such as Figure 3, in the next weeks, possibly refining the 
>>> statistics and the fit quality.
>>>
>>> We are also preparing additional material, dedicated to a more 
>>> detailed description of the data analysis procedure, which is posted 
>>> on a dedicated web RG-K wiki page, which is available at the link:
>>>
>>> All the material, including the attached document is available on the 
>>> , at the link:
>>>
>>> https://clasweb.jlab.org/wiki/index.php/Run_Group_K#tab=Jeopardy_Document 
>>>
>>>
>>> Please note that the present list of authors is limited to the list 
>>> of PI and dedicated students and post-doc. We are planning to 
>>> circulate the document among the original list authors to verify that 
>>> the scientific interest of the scientists and the institutes they 
>>> belong to is still vivid.
>>>
>>> We will be pleased to promptly address all your inputs to improve the 
>>> quality of the scope of the document.
>>>
>>> Thank you for your attention and support
>>>
>>> Annalisa D'Angelo
>>>
>>> for the RG-K
>>>