[clas12_rgk] [EXTERNAL] Re: Internal jeopardy review for PAC48 - RG-K document - second version

[Dave Ireland]

Dear Annalisa,

Thanks for sending the amended jeopardy proposal for run group K. You 
have addressed all the issues raised, and made changes to the document 
that were requested.

You may still want to tweak things, but as far as the substance of the 
document is concerned it is ready to submit to the PAC. I am happy to 
discuss any further points if you still want advice, but there is 
nothing further from our side.

Apologies for being a day late!

Best wishes,

Dave



On 10/06/2020 09:45, Annalisa D'Angelo wrote:
> To the Chair of the CLAS Internal Review Committee - Prof. David Ireland
> 
> To the Chair of the CLAS Collaboration - Prof. Kyungseon Joo
> 
> please find in attachment the second version of the document we are 
> preparing for the PAC48  Jeopardy Review Committee, together with the 
> detailed replay to the First Round comments.
> 
> All the material, including the attached document is also available on 
> the , at the link:
> 
> https://clasweb.jlab.org/wiki/index.php/Run_Group_K#tab=Jeopardy_Document
> 
> 
> Thank you for your attention and support
> 
> Annalisa D'Angelo
> 
> for the RG-K
> Il 03/06/20 10:40, Dave Ireland ha scritto:
>> Dear Annalisa,
>>
>> Please find attached the review committee's initial comments on the 
>> run group K jeopardy document. You may need clarification on what some 
>> comments mean, so we would encourage you to discuss these in a call 
>> with us. As you know, I am the lead reviewer for this run group, so 
>> would be the first person to contact, but the others are happy to 
>> participate if the time is available.
>>
>> Kyungseon's timeline (below) is for revised documents to be submitted 
>> by June 9.
>>
>> Best wishes,
>>
>> Dave,
>> for the jeopardy committee:
>> Charles Hyde-Wright
>> Zein-Eddine Meziani
>>
>> -----
>>
>> Timeline:
>> • 4/22/2020: Committee members start to communicate with run-group 
>> leaders. [DONE]
>> • 5/26/2020: Run-group leaders send their initial draft due to Chair 
>> of jeopardy review committee. [DONE]
>> • 6/2/2020: First round recommendations sent to run group-leaders [DONE]
>> • 6/9/2020: Revised documents sent to Chair of jeopardy review committee
>> • 6/16/2020: Final recommendations sent to run group-leaders
>> • 6/22/2020: Submit jeopardy updates due to PAC48
>>
>>
>>
>> On 26/05/2020 10:55, Annalisa D'Angelo wrote:
>>> To the Chair of the CLAS Internal Review Committee - Prof. David Ireland
>>>
>>> To the Chair of the CLAS Collaboration - Prof. Kyungseon Joo
>>>
>>> please find in attachment the Initial draft of the document we are 
>>> preparing for the PAC48  Jeopardy Review Committee. The document 
>>> reflects the present status of the preliminary analysis of the 
>>> available RG-K fall 2018 data. We expect to improve some of the 
>>> figures, such as Figure 3, in the next weeks, possibly refining the 
>>> statistics and the fit quality.
>>>
>>> We are also preparing additional material, dedicated to a more 
>>> detailed description of the data analysis procedure, which is posted 
>>> on a dedicated web RG-K wiki page, which is available at the link:
>>>
>>> All the material, including the attached document is available on the 
>>> , at the link:
>>>
>>> https://clasweb.jlab.org/wiki/index.php/Run_Group_K#tab=Jeopardy_Document 
>>>
>>>
>>> Please note that the present list of authors is limited to the list 
>>> of PI and dedicated students and post-doc. We are planning to 
>>> circulate the document among the original list authors to verify that 
>>> the scientific interest of the scientists and the institutes they 
>>> belong to is still vivid.
>>>
>>> We will be pleased to promptly address all your inputs to improve the 
>>> quality of the scope of the document.
>>>
>>> Thank you for your attention and support
>>>
>>> Annalisa D'Angelo
>>>
>>> for the RG-K
>>>