[Clascomment] OPT-IN: Exclusive pi-0 electroproduction at W > 2 GeV with CLAS
Volker Burkert
burkert at jlab.org
Mon Apr 21 19:12:43 EDT 2014
Dear lead authors.
I want to congratulate you to a very nice paper. It is very well written and has a clear message.
I have only one complaint/request. My request is related to Fig. 20 and Fig. 24. The way the
Figures are designed really does not do justice to the beautiful data that we are about to publish.
The most precise data are crammed into the smallest space at low xB and low Q2, while the
least precise data and fewest data points have been given the vast space available at large xB
and large Q2. THIS IS NOT RIGHT!
The remedy for this is to plot the data in a similar way to how it is done in Fig. 17. There you
have used a "distorted-log" scale for the horizontal axis that makes all boxes to have the
same size. I suggest to use the same "trick" for Fig. 20 and Fig. 24. The PRC editor and the
readers will be thankful!
Volker
More information about the Clascomment
mailing list