[Clascomment] answers to your comments on the dvcs prd - eg1dvcs

[GUIDAL Michel (57321)]

Dear all,

We are possibly close to find a compromise.

I would just have the suggestion (request ?) to add a footnote on l.1177, 
just after "Eight CFF-related real quantities", something like:
\footnote{These quantites are actually called CFFs in this particular work 
[refs if necessary].} or something like that, I let you find the best 
phrasing.

This would have the merit, besides paying due respect and tribute to
the work of Refs.[32,34,35,36], to possibly avoid to change the title of
section VIII, as well as the first sentence:
"In recent years, various groups have developed and applied
different procedures to extract Compton Form Factors
from DVCS observables" since, with the definition of eq.8,
and since we want to be ultra-orthodox, nobody actually fits
and extracts the so-defined "CFFs".

"Incidentally", the name of Radyushkin is missing in the
2nd reference of Ref.23.

For Michel, the "previous" version of the article I was alluding
to, where the "alternate" definition of CFFs was well into place, was in: 
"https://clasweb.jlab.org/membership/publist.php" (first paper
of the list).

Amities,

Michel

On Wed, 14 Jan 2015, Garcon Michel wrote:

> 
> Dear Silvia,
> 
>  
> 
>                 For lack of better solution, the compromise suggested by
> Silvia N. is fine with me. Like Chief Joseph, “I will fight no more
> forever”.
> 
>  
> 
> I just note for Michel that the draft of this paper which was posted for
> comments had the CFFs defined as 4 complex form factors everywhere, before I
> sent my comments. Only one equation (ImF) was not consistent with that
> definition.         
> 
>  
> 
> But somebody else said “never say never”, and maybe this controversy will
> continue on other papers. But then, I will wait if and when other colleagues
> want to raise this issue.
> 
>  
> 
> Thank you for your answers to my comments and best regards,
> 
>                                                Michel.
> 
>  
> 
> _______________
> 
> Michel Garçon
> 
> Irfu/SPhN                                               
> 
> CEA-Saclay, bât. 703                              
> 
> 91191 Gif-sur-Yvette cedex       
> 
> France                                           
> 
> Tél.: +33 1 69 08 86 23
> 
> 
>

-- 
***
Michel GUIDAL
Institut de Physique Nucleaire
Bat 100 - M019
91406 ORSAY Cedex
Tel: (33) 01 69 15 73 21
Fax: (33) 01 69 15 64 70
E-mail: guidal at ipno.in2p3.fr
***