[G12] Fwd: Momentum corrections

[Paul Eugenio]

Begin forwarded message:

> From: Matt <mbellis at stanford.edu>
> Date: April 14, 2010 8:27:53 PM EDT
> To: mamaryan at odu.edu
> Cc: Heghine Seraydaryan <heghines at jlab.org>, g12 at jlab.org, Paul Eugenio <eugenio at fsu.edu>, Larry Weinstein <lweinste at odu.edu>
> Subject: Re: [G12] Momentum corrections
> 
> Hi all,
> 
>    Paul, this may get bounced from the g12 mailing list, as I am emailing from a different address than from which I originally subscribed. Could you please forward it to that list as a record of this conversation. 
>  
> As for the Bellis analysis, I believe his work was shown to
> have some problems that were not addressed, including
> the fact that his proton momenta were not sensible, etc.
> 
>    That is absolutely not true, Moskov, and you are trying to either misrepresent my work or you are willfully ignoring *multiple* discussions we had on this matter and which is documented in emails and on the Wiki. There were *never* any issues with any mass plots or cuts that were made in my analysis. There was *one* independent set of plots that were made in order to compare other momentum distributions to ODU's work and the issue was with a definition of transverse momentum in Mike William's 4vec class. This has been gone over *MANY* times with you and Larry and Igor and others and it was *NEVER* used to make any cuts on the analysis. 
> 
>    There were *NEVER* any *physics* issues raised with my analysis, Moskov, though this is not the first time that you have tried to misrepresent that work. I am disappointed that after we had a similar email conversation last year on this *very same issue*, that you try to pull this. I have always been as transparent as possible in every step of that analysis and those discussions.
> 
>    I have no idea what the ODU group is doing now, so I cannot comment on it. But do not think that a plotting issue that was solved *days after* we showed it at a meeting, in any way discredits the work that I did, nor that it strengthens any of the previous ODU analysis. 
> 
> -- 
> -- 
> ----------------------------
> Matt Bellis
> Stanford University
> (SLAC office)  650-926-4392
> (cell)    412-310-4586
> ----------------------------

--
Prof. Paul Eugenio
Florida State University
Department of Physics
Tallahassee, Florida,  USA 32306

(850) 644-2585
eugenio at fsu.edu



-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: https://mailman.jlab.org/pipermail/g12/attachments/20100414/9161223a/attachment.html