[Mott] Fw: [EXTERNAL] [Web] resub CP10611 Grames

[Joe Grames]

Hi Folks,

I just uploaded the requested corrections to the APS website.   Many thanks to Daniel, Danny, Marcy, Scott and Riad for modifying those 14 figures so rapidly.   Whereas some figures were just cut/pasted in Word before, we now have a unique file corresponding to each figure for posterity.  Finally, thanks to Kurt Aulenbacher, who gave us permission to produce our version of his Figure 2.

And thanks to Charlie who noticed, quite immediately I'd say, that our abstract was 'muffed' on the APS website.  That's now addressed too: https://journals.aps.org/prc/accepted/80079P20C9e1340736b916c11e2403857a4921c86

It ain't over til it's over, but I think we can see the finish line.

Seems like Friday COB is when all the magic happens.   Have a nice weekend.

Best,
Joe
________________________________________
From: esub-adm at aps.org <esub-adm at aps.org>
Sent: Friday, May 1, 2020 5:33 PM
To: Joe Grames
Subject: [EXTERNAL] [Web] resub CP10611 Grames

Subject: CP10611

Manuscript code: CP10611
RECVD: Fri May 01 17:33:23 2020
Resubmission to: PRC
Resubmission type: response


New files with this resubmission:
Figure19.pdf
Figure2.eps
PRC-3.pdf
PRC-3.docx
Figure18.eps
Figure22.eps
Figure20.eps

Deleted files from previous submission:
Figure20ab.eps
Figure22abcd.eps
Figure18abcd.eps
PRC-2.docx
PRC-2.pdf

Replaced files:
Figure4.pdf
Figure12.eps
Figure3.pdf
Figure7.pdf
Figure10.eps
Figure9.eps
Figure13.eps
Figure21.pdf
Figure11.eps

Response to editor/referee:
We have updated these 14 figures per the editor's request: 2,3,4,5,9-13,18-22.

Those new figures plus an updated version of manuscript including those figures are attached.

We contacted the editor about reproducing Figure 2 from another publication.  An important theoretical argument we are making is well supported by this figure already published in Rev. Sci. Instr.   We make it very clear in the text and caption that we are reproducing this figure, and we provide reference to the original publication.  Finally, we contacted one of the primary authors asking for permission to reproduce their figure and by the PRC style standards.   He agreed, please find attached screen grab of the e-mail exchange with K. Aulenbacher (Mainz University); his e-mail is shown as well.

Response attachments: Permission-Figure2.png

Remarks intended solely for the editor:


Previously suggested referees:
David Armstrong
William & Mary
armd at physics.wm.edu

Kurt Aulenbacher
Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz
aulenbac at kph.uni-mainz.de

Doris Jakubassa-Amundsenm
Mathematisches Institut der Universität München
dj at mathematik.uni-muenchen.de



Suggested referees:








By submitting this manuscript, the corresponding author certifies:

- The paper represents original work of the listed authors.

- The manuscript as presented accurately reflects the scientific results.

- All of the authors made significant contributions to the concept,
design, execution, or interpretation of the research study.

- All those who made significant contributions were offered the
opportunity to be listed as authors.

- All of the listed authors are aware of and agree to the submission
of this manuscript.

- The manuscript has not been published, and is not now and will not be
under consideration by another journal while it is considered here.

- The authors have provided information to the editors about relevant
unpublished manuscripts, including whether any version of this manuscript
was previously considered by an APS journal.

- The authors accept the established procedures for selecting
manuscripts for publication.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://mailman.jlab.org/pipermail/mott/attachments/20200501/f5884022/attachment-0001.html>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: PRC-3.pdf
Type: application/pdf
Size: 1376811 bytes
Desc: PRC-3.pdf
URL: <https://mailman.jlab.org/pipermail/mott/attachments/20200501/f5884022/attachment-0001.pdf>