[Clascomment] OPT-IN: Resolving the proton form factor problem by comparing electron and positron scattering from the proton

[Dave Ireland]

Hi Mac,

Thanks very much for reading through the comments and responses and for 
letting me know.

Larry: You can submit the paper to arXiv and PRL. Let me know when you 
do, and I can send a message to the collaboration to let them know to 
check the author list and contact you if there are any edit that need to 
be made.

Cheers,

Dave




On 11/24/14 16:09, Mac Mestayer wrote:
> Dear Dave;
>
> The paper review committee has considered the collaboration comments
> to the "TPE paper" and find that the authors have adequately
> answered all significant issues.  We approve the paper for submission
> for publications.
>
>              regards, Mac Mestayer (for the committee)
>
> "mestayer at jlab.org", (757)-269-7252
>
> On Mon, 24 Nov 2014, Larry Weinstein wrote:
>
>> Dear Mac, Mike, and Marco,
>>
>> Here are the final versions of the PRL paper draft and the
>> supplementary material.  The collaboration comments were excellent,
>> but mainly concerned minor details of grammar and syntax.  The primary
>> changes are that we have (1) toned down the title and (2) changed the
>> description of the statistical significance from a straight line fit
>> to a true confidence interval.  We now claim
>>
>>   Our data points plus the previous ε = 0 point [36] prefer the
>>   hadronic TPE calculation Ref. [17] by 2.5σover the no-TPE (R′ = 0)
>>   hypothesis. A calculation of TPE effects on a structureless point
>>   proton is disfavored by almost 5σ. Our results are consistent with
>>   the theoret- ical calculations and are more precise than the
>>   previousworld’s measurements.
>>
>> We are producing versions of figs 1 and 2 with larger labels and
>> higher resolution and will include them prior to publication.  If
>> desired, we can include a version of Fig 2 showing the high-epsilon
>> bins in the supplementary materials.
>>
>> We request permission to submit this paper to PRL.
>>
>> --
>>                 Sincerely,
>>                 Larry
>>
>> -----------------------------------------------------------
>> Lawrence Weinstein
>> University Professor
>> Physics Department
>> Old Dominion University
>> Norfolk, VA 23529
>> 757 683 5803
>> 757 683 3038 (fax)
>> weinstein at odu.edu
>> http://www.lions.odu.edu/~lweinste/
>>
>>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: David_Ireland.vcf
Type: text/x-vcard
Size: 327 bytes
Desc: not available
Url : https://mailman.jlab.org/pipermail/clascomment/attachments/20141124/7c9c8a67/attachment.vcf